Expert reviews and tasting notes from our team of reviewers
297 reviews found
Review
The Black Bowmore 1964 2nd Edition is a thirty-year-old Islay malt of extraordinary depth and rarity — a whisky that tra...
Read more
Joe Whitfield
February 11, 2026
Review
A 1966 Bowmore bottled at 35 years old by Douglas Laing's Old Malt Cask series — a rare window into Islay's golden era, ...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 11, 2026
Review
A 1979 vintage Port Ellen bottled by Gordon & MacPhail in 1995, this Connoisseurs Choice release captures the coastal so...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 8, 2026
Review
A twenty-five-year-old Lagavulin at cask strength from Diageo's prestigious Prima & Ultima series — Islay peat transform...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 6, 2026
Review
The 2005 Laphroaig 10 Cask Strength at 55.7% ABV is raw, uncompromising Islay — a collector's bottle that still delivers...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 4, 2026
Review
Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength in the litre format delivers the full uncompromising Islay experience at 55.7% ABV —...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 3, 2026
Review
A rare 1974 distillation bottled in 1994 for the 500th anniversary of Scotch whisky, this Ardbeg is a quiet, elegant pie...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 3, 2026
Review
A 46-year-old Bunnahabhain from 1971, bottled by Signatory at a gentle 42.8% — this is a rare time capsule from Islay's ...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 3, 2026
Review
A 28-year-old Ardbeg from 1974, bottled by Douglas Laing at natural strength — liquid archaeology from an era when the d...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 2, 2026
Review
A 1990-vintage Lagavulin Distillers Edition bottled in 2006, offering collectors a genuine piece of Islay history with t...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 1, 2026
Review
A 1967 Bruichladdich bottled by Signatory from a single sherry cask after 32 years — a genuine time capsule of pre-reviv...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 1, 2026
Review
A 1983 Port Ellen bottled by Hart Brothers after 14 years — a genuine piece of Islay history at 43% ABV that rewards qui...
Read more Joe Whitfield
February 1, 2026